BUILDING BLOCKS
For independent cafés, consistently good coffee remains essential. But in an increasingly competitive and cost-conscious market, quality alone is no longer enough to guarantee success.
With customers scrutinising where they spend their money, premium coffee still has a place, but the quality and experience need to clearly justify the price. For new and established operators, success depends on creating memorable experiences and building a commercially sustainable operation.
The first step is to understand that ‘better coffee’ means different things to different people. Taste is highly personal and evolves through experience. An espresso customer may expect something rich, chocolatey and intense, while a different person wants something bright and fruit-driven. These are simply different preferences and expectations of what great coffee tastes like – but how coffee is described and presented can be just as important as the product. Customers should be able to understand what they are ordering, without needing specialist knowledge.
For most cafés, that means starting with a clear, core coffee that appeals to the broadest possible audience. More distinctive processing methods and flavour profiles can be introduced later in an approachable way.
Operators also need to remember that they are building a hospitality business. Cafés fulfil many needs, from convenience and remote working to socialising and relaxation. Coffee is only part of the value customers buy, so the atmosphere, service and overall experience matter just as much.
SPECIAL SIGNATURE
Traditional speciality coffee often communicates value through origin, processing methods and quality scores. While these are important, the signals can be largely invisible to anyone outside the industry.
On the other hand, signature drinks are more commercially compelling and make that value more tangible. Customers can see the creativity, ingredients and craftsmanship involved, giving independents an opportunity to respond to wider trends to entice their customers.
Furthermore, signature drinks are increasingly becoming a core pillar of speciality coffee menus around the world, delivering increased customer spend and gross margin, while creating something distinctive that cannot be easily replicated by the café next door.
And in terms of Volcano Coffee Works, independent operators are fundamental to what we do. We have consciously focused on being a wholesale partner rather than building a large retail estate, because we believe our greatest value comes from supporting cafés and hospitality businesses.
With our success directly linked to theirs, we focus our people, investment and expertise on helping partners grow through coffee, equipment, technical services, training, menu development, seasonal drinks and marketing. For us, wholesale is more than a sales channel; it is an investment in the long-term success of the businesses we support.
PEOPLE FIRST
With rising rents, energy costs, wages and particularly business rates, operators are facing an incredibly challenging trading environment. At the same time, consumers have more choice than ever.
Many larger cities are already densely saturated, making it increasingly difficult for new businesses to stand out. At the same time, recruiting and retaining good people remains challenging. Furthermore, coffee alone is rarely enough to sustain a successful café. Food, retail products and additional revenue streams are important to generate success but can also introduce complexity, cost and operational risk.
However, there’s still enormous opportunity – and it all comes down to understanding your customer. The best-performing cafés are those that consider value from their perspective, rather than relying solely on the industry’s traditional definition of speciality coffee. As competition increases, independents have a real opportunity to innovate around experience, relevance and hospitality, while remaining closely connected to the communities they serve.
Another key consideration is the barista, as visible craftsmanship is key.
Our philosophy is to automate the invisible tasks, while preserving the craftsmanship and hospitality that gives a café its character. Automation should absolutely be adopted where it improves consistency, tamping, quality and efficiency to workflow management. This gives baristas more time doing what machines can’t, including welcoming customers, making recommendations and creating a memorable experience. In addition, customers value seeing care and skill go into what they are buying, and the barista remains a visible signal of quality.
In settings where coffee preparation takes place away from the customer, such as hotels or restaurants, coffee expertise is still valuable, to help guests navigate different choices, making the experience feel considered rather than transactional.
When it comes to the future, coffee has never been more competitive. The successful independents we see truly understand the customer, and value their perspective rather than the industry’s. Their advantage lies in being personal, relevant and closely connected to their customers.
That said, technical expertise also remains important – but to create better experiences, rather than simply demonstrate expertise. This is where the future of coffee will lie.
For more info: